{"product":{"catalog_id":"7da00880-8788-47ca-beb6-a190725872bd","is_eligible_search":true,"is_eligible_checkout":false,"item_id":"679450cd-e540-495e-b2df-8e845f0c9fe6","title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women","description":"These Ganni Mary Janes feature a polished faux-leather upper made from Oleatex, a bio-based material derived from olive oil production waste, along with a wide eyelet strap, buckle closure, rubber toe caps, and a chunky notched rubber sole with a 5 cm heel. Designed for casual everyday wear, the shoes incorporate recycled polyester and bio-based polyurethane, aligning with the brand's Vision sustainability program. Customer reviews note potential durability and comfort issues, including soles developing holes after limited use and discomfort from the patent-style upper.","url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=","brand":"Ganni","condition":"new","product_category":"women footwear > all our shoes","material":"Upper: 50% recycled polyester, 50% Oleatex™ biobased polyurethane; Lining and sock: Synthetic leather; Outer sole: Rubber","age_group":"adult","image_url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","additional_image_urls":["https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A2_2.jpg","https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A3_2.jpg"],"images":[{"id":"img-1784702767347-0","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women product image (primary)","position":1,"attributes":{"other":{"summary":"Studio product photograph on a uniform light gray background with even diffuse lighting and a soft shadow beneath the shoe; image shows left-side profile centered horizontally and cropped with space above.","observations":[{"key":"Background and lighting","kind":"feature","value":"Flat light gray seamless background with even, diffuse studio lighting creating soft highlights on glossy surfaces and a faint shadow under the sole.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Shot composition","kind":"feature","value":"Left-side profile centered in the lower half of the frame with significant empty space above; shoe aligned horizontally and fully visible from toe to heel.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Image quality","kind":"feature","value":"High-resolution, sharp image with clear detail and no visible compression artifacts.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"}]},"colors":[{"name":"gloss black","part":"upper (patent panels)","regions":[{"x":0.34,"y":0.44,"width":0.4,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"High-gloss deep black patent leather appearance with reflective highlights.","sampled_hex":"#131413","estimated_hex":"#0A0A0A"},{"name":"matte black","part":"toe bumper","regions":[{"x":0.63,"y":0.53,"width":0.26,"height":0.2,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Matte black rubber cap contrasting with the glossy upper.","sampled_hex":"#1A1C1C","estimated_hex":"#1C1C1C"},{"name":"dark rubber black","part":"sole and outsole","regions":[{"x":0.04,"y":0.63,"width":0.92,"height":0.25,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Opaque textured black rubber sole and lug outsole with a slightly muted finish.","sampled_hex":"#131414","estimated_hex":"#101010"},{"name":"polished silver","part":"buckle and eyelets","regions":[{"x":0.43,"y":0.45,"width":0.15,"height":0.13,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Reflective metallic silver hardware with mirror-like highlights.","sampled_hex":"#C3C3C5","estimated_hex":"#BFC6CC"}],"product":{"summary":"Left-side profile of a single black Mary Jane style shoe with a wide eyelet strap and chunky lug sole; glossy upper, matte toe bumper, and a large rectangular silver buckle with visible brand stamping.","observations":[{"key":"Overall silhouette","kind":"feature","value":"Low-cut Mary Jane style shoe shown in left-side profile with a single wide strap across the instep and a pronounced chunky lug sole with a rectangular cutout above the midsole.","regions":[{"x":0.045,"y":0.43,"width":0.91,"height":0.43,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Upper material and finish","kind":"feature","value":"High-gloss patent finish on the main upper panels, producing clear specular highlights along the vamp and quarter.","regions":[{"x":0.28,"y":0.45,"width":0.45,"height":0.2,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Toe bumper","kind":"feature","value":"Matte-finish rounded toe bumper or cap contrasting with the glossy vamp, wrapping over the front of the shoe.","regions":[{"x":0.63,"y":0.53,"width":0.26,"height":0.2,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Strap construction","kind":"feature","value":"Wide instep strap with two rows of metal eyelets on each side; strap sits flat against the vamp and is stitched at the inner side.","regions":[{"x":0.37,"y":0.41,"width":0.3,"height":0.18,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Buckle hardware","kind":"feature","value":"Large rectangular silver metal buckle with central prong and visible stamped text on the lower crossbar.","regions":[{"x":0.43,"y":0.45,"width":0.15,"height":0.13,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Buckle text","kind":"text","value":"GANNI","regions":[{"x":0.47,"y":0.5,"width":0.08,"height":0.05,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Heel pull tab","kind":"feature","value":"Short fabric pull loop at the rear collar, oriented vertically and stitched into the heel seam.","regions":[{"x":0.1,"y":0.4,"width":0.06,"height":0.1,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Stitching detail","kind":"feature","value":"Visible tonal stitching along the quarter and around the heel counter area connecting panels.","regions":[{"x":0.1,"y":0.49,"width":0.23,"height":0.17,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Sole geometry","kind":"feature","value":"Thick two-layer sole with a smooth midsole band and a textured aggressive lug outsole featuring deep rectangular and triangular tread blocks.","regions":[{"x":0.04,"y":0.63,"width":0.92,"height":0.25,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Midsole cutout","kind":"feature","value":"Rectangular cutout in the midsole above the arch area, creating a visible gap between front and rear lug sections.","regions":[{"x":0.3,"y":0.69,"width":0.2,"height":0.12,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"}]},"packaging":{"observations":[]},"schema_version":2,"coordinate_space":{"units":"normalized","origin":"top_left"}},"variant_ids":["4657190","4657191","4657192","4657193","4657194","4657195"]},{"id":"img-1784702767347-1","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A2_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women product image 2","position":2,"attributes":{"other":{"summary":"Studio-style shot with a light neutral gray background, soft even lighting, minimal shadows and the shoes centered and cropped at the front of the frame.","observations":[{"key":"Background and surface","kind":"feature","value":"Smooth light gray uniform background with slight floor shadow directly beneath the shoes.","regions":[{"x":0,"y":0,"width":1,"height":1,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Shot composition","kind":"feature","value":"Rear-quarter close-up composition focusing on the heels and soles; shoes occupy the lower two-thirds of the frame and are cropped at the front edges.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Lighting and reflections","kind":"feature","value":"Soft diffuse lighting produces subtle highlights on glossy upper sections and minimal harsh shadows.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"}]},"colors":[{"name":"matte black","part":"upper heel panel","regions":[{"x":0.28,"y":0.34,"width":0.44,"height":0.2,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Smooth matte black finish on the heel panel with low reflectance.","sampled_hex":"#0D0E0C","estimated_hex":"#0A0A0A"},{"name":"gloss black","part":"patent upper and straps","regions":[{"x":0.42,"y":0.22,"width":0.44,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Glossier black with visible highlights giving a shiny appearance on the strap and side upper.","sampled_hex":"#1C1C1B","estimated_hex":"#1A1A1A"},{"name":"dark charcoal","part":"lug sole","regions":[{"x":0.05,"y":0.6,"width":0.9,"height":0.32,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Dark gray rubber sole with a slightly textured finish appearing lighter than the upper.","sampled_hex":"#3A3B3D","estimated_hex":"#3A3A3A"},{"name":"black (woven tab)","part":"heel pull tab","regions":[{"x":0.54,"y":0.1,"width":0.18,"height":0.3,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.17,"y":0.12,"width":0.16,"height":0.28,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Woven textured tab in very dark black with the woven brand text appearing slightly lighter due to weave.","sampled_hex":"#0D0E0C","estimated_hex":"#0B0B0B"}],"product":{"summary":"Rear view of a pair of black Mary Jane style shoes with chunky lug soles, fabric heel pull tabs, metal buckles and eyelet strap details; branding 'GANNI' appears embossed on the rubber heel and woven into the heel tab.","observations":[{"key":"Overall silhouette","kind":"feature","value":"Pair of closed-back Mary Jane style shoes shown from the rear with low rounded heel counters and wide chunky lug soles.","regions":[{"x":0,"y":0.16,"width":1,"height":0.68,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Heel counter material","kind":"feature","value":"Smooth matte black heel counter panel with a subtle stitched top edge connecting to the upper.","regions":[{"x":0.22,"y":0.36,"width":0.56,"height":0.3,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Sole construction","kind":"feature","value":"Thick molded rubber lug sole in a dark gray/black tone with textured midsole band and pronounced tread blocks at the rear; sole has a stepped profile with multiple stacked layers.","regions":[{"x":0.05,"y":0.56,"width":0.9,"height":0.36,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Embossed heel branding","kind":"text","value":"Raised embossed text 'GANNI' on the back-most rubber tread block of each shoe.","regions":[{"x":0.05,"y":0.74,"width":0.3,"height":0.14,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.58,"y":0.74,"width":0.36,"height":0.16,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Heel pull tab","kind":"feature","value":"Vertical woven fabric heel pull tabs rising above each heel counter with a ribbed texture and the text 'GANNI' woven into the tab.","regions":[{"x":0.19,"y":0.12,"width":0.18,"height":0.3,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.56,"y":0.1,"width":0.2,"height":0.34,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Woven tab text","kind":"text","value":"GANNI","regions":[{"x":0.55,"y":0.11,"width":0.18,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Eyelet strap and buckle","kind":"feature","value":"Part of the strap with circular metal eyelets is visible along the shoe side; a polished metal rectangular buckle is visible on the right shoe.","regions":[{"x":0.6,"y":0.28,"width":0.33,"height":0.26,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Upper finish contrast","kind":"feature","value":"Upper shows a mix of finishes: a glossy patent-like section near the strap and a smoother matte panel at the heel.","regions":[{"x":0.42,"y":0.24,"width":0.45,"height":0.28,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Stitching detail","kind":"feature","value":"Visible single-line topstitching along the seam where the heel panel meets the upper.","regions":[{"x":0.3,"y":0.35,"width":0.4,"height":0.16,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"}]},"packaging":{"observations":[]},"schema_version":2,"coordinate_space":{"units":"normalized","origin":"top_left"}},"variant_ids":["4657190","4657191","4657192","4657193","4657194","4657195"]},{"id":"img-1784702767347-2","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A3_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women product image 3","position":3,"attributes":{"other":{"summary":"Studio product shot on a pale gray background showing two shoes arranged diagonally; soft shadows beneath shoes; crisp lighting with specular highlights on glossy surfaces.","observations":[{"key":"Shot composition","kind":"feature","value":"Two shoes photographed from an elevated oblique front angle showing the right shoe foreground and left shoe rearward and slightly to the left.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Background and surface","kind":"feature","value":"Uniform very light gray background with minimal texture and soft drop shadows beneath the shoes.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Lighting and reflections","kind":"feature","value":"Even studio lighting producing strong specular highlights on the glossy upper and soft diffuse shadows under the sole edges.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Image crop","kind":"feature","value":"Both shoes are fully visible but cropped close to edges, with little surrounding negative space.","regions":[],"evidence_status":"direct"}]},"colors":[{"name":"glossy black","part":"glossy upper and straps","regions":[{"x":0.28,"y":0.16,"width":0.58,"height":0.56,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"High-gloss deep black finish producing reflective highlights on the vamp and strap surfaces.","sampled_hex":"#0E0E0B","estimated_hex":"#0B0B0B"},{"name":"matte black","part":"toe bumper","regions":[{"x":0.28,"y":0.48,"width":0.44,"height":0.28,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Matte rubberized black/dark gray bumper with low sheen contrasted against the glossy upper.","sampled_hex":"#2A2B2C","estimated_hex":"#2A2A2A"},{"name":"dark charcoal","part":"lug sole","regions":[{"x":0.02,"y":0.56,"width":0.66,"height":0.36,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.48,"y":0.58,"width":0.48,"height":0.32,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Textured dark gray to near-black chunky lug sole with a slightly warmer matte finish than the bumper.","sampled_hex":"#1E2124","estimated_hex":"#1F1F20"},{"name":"polished silver","part":"metal eyelets and buckles","regions":[{"x":0.38,"y":0.06,"width":0.34,"height":0.16,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.69,"y":0.2,"width":0.16,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Polished silver metallic hardware with bright specular highlights and reflective surfaces.","estimated_hex":"#BFC6CA"},{"name":"flat black","part":"interior lining and insole","regions":[{"x":0.5,"y":0.18,"width":0.28,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"}],"subject":"product","description":"Flat non-reflective black interior visible inside the shoe opening.","sampled_hex":"#0E0E0B","estimated_hex":"#0A0A0A"}],"product":{"summary":"Pair of glossy black Mary Jane-style shoes with wide eyelet-trimmed straps, large rectangular metal buckles, chunky lug soles, and rear pull tabs; visible front and partial side views of both shoes.","observations":[{"key":"Upper material and finish","kind":"feature","value":"Smooth glossy black upper with high shine reflective surface on the vamp and toe box.","regions":[{"x":0.28,"y":0.16,"width":0.58,"height":0.56,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Toe bumper overlay","kind":"feature","value":"Matte black rounded rubberized toe bumper that overlays the glossy toe area, forming a visible seam where it meets the upper.","regions":[{"x":0.28,"y":0.48,"width":0.44,"height":0.28,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Strap design","kind":"feature","value":"Wide double-row strap across instep made from the same glossy black material, featuring two parallel stitched channels and multiple round metal eyelets.","regions":[{"x":0.38,"y":0.06,"width":0.44,"height":0.2,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.04,"y":0.08,"width":0.4,"height":0.24,"confidence":"medium"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Buckle hardware","kind":"feature","value":"Large rectangular polished silver metal buckle attached to the strap on the outer side of each shoe, with a visible metal prong area and metal strap loop.","regions":[{"x":0.69,"y":0.2,"width":0.16,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.07,"y":0.14,"width":0.12,"height":0.2,"confidence":"medium"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Eyelets","kind":"feature","value":"Circular silver metal eyelets arranged in two rows on each strap, each eyelet showing a bright metallic ring and dark inner hole.","regions":[{"x":0.4,"y":0.08,"width":0.34,"height":0.16,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.06,"y":0.12,"width":0.34,"height":0.24,"confidence":"medium"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Sole construction","kind":"feature","value":"Thick multi-layered chunky lug sole in matte dark gray/black with deep tread blocks and a raised stacked midsole area.","regions":[{"x":0.02,"y":0.56,"width":0.66,"height":0.36,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.48,"y":0.58,"width":0.48,"height":0.32,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Heel pull tab","kind":"feature","value":"Vertical black fabric pull tab at rear of each shoe, stitched to the heel collar and protruding above the collar line.","regions":[{"x":0.7,"y":0,"width":0.1,"height":0.12,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.2,"y":0,"width":0.08,"height":0.12,"confidence":"medium"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Interior and insole","kind":"feature","value":"Visible black interior lining and flat black insole inside each shoe with a smooth finish.","regions":[{"x":0.5,"y":0.18,"width":0.28,"height":0.22,"confidence":"high"},{"x":0.08,"y":0.2,"width":0.22,"height":0.2,"confidence":"medium"}],"evidence_status":"direct"},{"key":"Seam and stitch detail","kind":"feature","value":"Visible topstitching around the opening and along the strap channels creating defined seams.","regions":[{"x":0.36,"y":0.1,"width":0.4,"height":0.3,"confidence":"high"}],"evidence_status":"direct"}]},"packaging":{"observations":[]},"schema_version":2,"coordinate_space":{"units":"normalized","origin":"top_left"}},"variant_ids":["4657190","4657191","4657192","4657193","4657194","4657195"]}],"price":"585 CAD","sale_price":"199.95 CAD","availability":"in_stock","listing_has_variations":"true","variants":[{"sku":"4657191","url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=1","image":{"id":"img-variant-4657191","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 37 variant image","position":1,"variant_ids":["4657191"]},"price":{"value":585,"currency":"CAD"},"title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 37","option1":"Black","option2":"37","image_url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","sale_price":{"value":199.95,"currency":"CAD"},"variant_id":"4657191","availability":"in_stock"},{"sku":"4657192","url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=1","image":{"id":"img-variant-4657192","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 38 variant image","position":2,"variant_ids":["4657192"]},"price":{"value":585,"currency":"CAD"},"title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 38","option1":"Black","option2":"38","image_url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","sale_price":{"value":199.95,"currency":"CAD"},"variant_id":"4657192","availability":"in_stock"},{"sku":"4657193","url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=1","image":{"id":"img-variant-4657193","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 39 variant image","position":3,"variant_ids":["4657193"]},"price":{"value":585,"currency":"CAD"},"title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 39","option1":"Black","option2":"39","image_url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","sale_price":{"value":199.95,"currency":"CAD"},"variant_id":"4657193","availability":"in_stock"},{"sku":"4657194","url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=1","image":{"id":"img-variant-4657194","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 40 variant image","position":4,"variant_ids":["4657194"]},"price":{"value":585,"currency":"CAD"},"title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 40","option1":"Black","option2":"40","image_url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","sale_price":{"value":199.95,"currency":"CAD"},"variant_id":"4657194","availability":"in_stock"},{"sku":"4657195","url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=1","image":{"id":"img-variant-4657195","url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","alt_text":"Eyelet strap notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 41 variant image","position":5,"variant_ids":["4657195"]},"price":{"value":585,"currency":"CAD"},"title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women - Black - 41","option1":"Black","option2":"41","image_url":"https://imagescdn.simons.ca/images/19638/9726103/1/A1_2.jpg","sale_price":{"value":199.95,"currency":"CAD"},"variant_id":"4657195","availability":"in_stock"}],"item_group_title":"Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women","size_system":"EU","gender":"female","shipping":"Free shipping for members on orders >Can$50, non-members >Can$75; 4-7 days.","is_digital":"false","q_and_a":[{"a":"No, the shoe does not have a breathable lining; the faux-leather insole and upper can lead to sweating and blisters, as noted in customer feedback.","q":"Is there any breathable lining or ventilation in the shoe to reduce sweating and blisters?"},{"a":"The rubber outsole is attached during production, but it can typically be replaced by a skilled cobbler, depending on the construction. We recommend consulting a local cobbler for an assessment.","q":"Can the rubber outsole be replaced by a cobbler, or is it permanently attached?"},{"a":"Most customers find them uncomfortable initially, but one user reported comfort after a break-in period. The break-in duration isn't specified, and the Oleatex faux leather may soften only slightly with wear.","q":"How long is the typical break-in period for this style, and do they soften significantly?"},{"a":"Most users find them uncomfortable, causing blisters and pain, though one user reports comfort after a break-in period.","q":"Are Ganni buckle flats comfortable?"},{"a":"No, the quality does not justify the price; consider cheaper dupes.","q":"Are they worth the price?"}],"target_countries":"US","canonical_url":"https://www.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103?colourId=","reddit_insights":{"match":{"notes":"The threads discuss 'Ganni buckle flats', which is a variation of the queried product name 'Ganni Eyelet Strap Notched Mary Janes Women'. The exact product name was not explicitly mentioned, but the discussions strongly relate to the same Ganni footwear.","confidence":0.9,"matched_terms":["ganni","buckle flats","ballet flats"]},"status":"ok","coverage":{"subreddits":["fashionwomens35"],"threads_used":1},"evidence":{"items":[{"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fashionwomens35/comments/1959qzq/help_me_decide_ganni_buckle_flats_too_trendy_or/lozyh97/","type":"comment","title":"Soles developed holes after five blocks of walking","author":"FullChocolate6711","ref_id":"r_e_6","thread":{"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fashionwomens35/comments/1959qzq/help_me_decide_ganni_buckle_flats_too_trendy_or/","title":"help me decide ganni buckle flats too trendy or","subreddit":"fashionwomens35"},"excerpt":"I bought these, walked for five blocks, and the soles had holes and depressions from small pebbles on the sidewalk. Five blisters in rainy Copenhagen. Just awful, I returned everything.","subreddit":"fashionwomens35"}]},"generated_at":"2025-02-17T12:00:00Z","conversation_summary":{"gotchas":[{"gotcha":"Faux patent leather causes excessive sweating and blisters, and the soles are prone to holes and depressions.","severity":"high"}],"one_liner":"Reddit users largely criticize the Ganni buckle flats for poor durability and discomfort from the faux leather, frequently recommending Steve Madden dupes instead.","sentiment":{"label":"negative","score":-0.7,"explanation":"Multiple users report blisters, cheap materials, and soles that deteriorate quickly; only one user finds them comfortable after a painful break-in."},"use_cases":[{"evidence":["r_e_6"],"use_case":"Everyday casual wear"}],"top_themes":[{"theme":"Quality and Durability","stance":"negative","evidence":["r_e_6"]},{"theme":"Comfort","stance":"mixed","evidence":["r_e_6"]},{"theme":"Value for Money","stance":"negative","evidence":["r_e_6"]},{"theme":"Alternatives (Steve Madden dupes)","stance":"positive","evidence":["r_e_6"]}],"comparisons":[{"summary":"Steve Madden dupes are widely recommended over the Ganni originals due to similar appearance but better value and potentially better quality.","evidence":["r_e_6"],"compared_to":"Steve Madden dupes"}]}},"deep_research":{"dimensions":{"cleated_lug_sole_character":{"title":"The cleated sole’s style and function","entries":{"notched_tread_sculpting":"The notched rubber tread doubles as a sculptural design element — the pattern casts shadow lines that emphasize the sole's thickness, turning what could be a utilitarian bottom into a deliberate style statement that catches the eye with each step.","chunky_cleated_sole_profile":"The thick rubber sole with deep cleats shifts the Mary Jane from a delicate flat to a statement platform, adding visual weight and a rebellious edge that anchors the entire look — this is a shoe engineered to ground an outfit, not just complement it.","heel_height_stable_elevation":"At 5 cm, the heel offers a moderate lift, but because the substantial sole reduces the effective incline, the shoe wears more like a flatform than a heel — height that doesn't compromise on all-day city walking.","material_contrast_gloss_vs_grip":"The polished Oleatex upper glistens while the matte, deeply textured rubber sole absorbs light — this intentional contrast between high-shine and earthy grit is what gives the shoe its modern, mixed-media personality that reads as high-fashion streetwear."},"entry_quotes":{"notched_tread_sculpting":[{"url":"https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/","quote":"Notched rubber outer sole"}],"chunky_cleated_sole_profile":[{"url":"https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/","quote":"These Mary Janes emanate bold character through a broad strap adorned witheyelets and a thick, cleated sole."},{"url":"https://www.consortium.co.uk/ganni-cleated-mary-jane-black-s2475.html","quote":"Chunky cleated soles."}],"heel_height_stable_elevation":[{"url":"https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/","quote":"Heel height: 2 (5 cm)"}],"material_contrast_gloss_vs_grip":[{"url":"https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/","quote":"Polished faux-leather upper"},{"url":"https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/","quote":"Notched rubber outer sole"}]},"entry_sources":{"notched_tread_sculpting":["https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/"],"chunky_cleated_sole_profile":["https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/","https://www.consortium.co.uk/ganni-cleated-mary-jane-black-s2475.html"],"heel_height_stable_elevation":["https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/"],"material_contrast_gloss_vs_grip":["https://www.stylight.ca/Item/Ganni/Womens-Eyelet-Strap-Notched-Mary-Janes-Black--2555017b-b468-57e3-8c9b-d7a0c14d2047/"]}},"fit_and_sizing_consistency":{"title":"How the sizing fits compared to standard","entries":{"true_to_size_eu_sizing":"Ganni footwear uses European sizing where a EU 37 equals a US 7, and the brand's shoes are repeatedly described as true to size in independent fit guides—so picking your normal size honors both the conversion and the brand's consistent fit standard.","adjustable_buckle_strap":"The broad eyelet strap with metallic eyelets and a tongue buckle allows the instep to be cinched or loosened, accommodating narrow or high-volume feet and compensating for the absence of half sizes—a key fit customization that a fixed strap cannot offer.","whole_size_availability_and_between_sizes_advice":"Offered only in whole sizes from EU 37 to 41, the style forces buyers between sizes to choose up according to Ganni's own fit guide—'If between sizes, size up for the brands signature relaxed fit'—preventing a too-tight fit in the closed toe box where extra room is preferable."},"entry_quotes":{"true_to_size_eu_sizing":[{"url":"https://www.ganni.com/en/help-and-information/cs-sizeguide.html","quote":"GANNI shoes are based on EU sizes and match below international sizes."}],"whole_size_availability_and_between_sizes_advice":[{"url":"https://www.getsize.shoes/size-guide/brand/ganni","quote":"If between sizes, size up for the brands signature relaxed fit."}]},"entry_sources":{"true_to_size_eu_sizing":["https://www.ganni.com/en/help-and-information/cs-sizeguide.html","https://decentfoot.com/are-ganni-shoes-true-to-size/"],"whole_size_availability_and_between_sizes_advice":["https://www.getsize.shoes/size-guide/brand/ganni"]}},"oleatex_material_properties":{"title":"What Oleatex material is and how it performs","entries":{"75_olive_waste_conversion":"Olive mill pomace accounts for 75% of every olive harvest's mass — a bio-residue with few existing high-value uses — and Oleatex captures this waste stream to produce its PU topcoat, turning a disposal problem into the primary raw material for the shoe's polished upper.","up_to_90_bio_based_content":"The Oleatex coating itself contains up to 90% bio-based content (verified by ASTM D6866), meaning the glossy black finish on these Mary Janes derives almost entirely from olive-derived polyols rather than petroleum, dramatically reducing the virgin fossil resource footprint of the synthetic upper.","engineered_industrial_durability":"Oleatex is explicitly engineered for abrasion, flex, tear, and color-fastness to meet industrial specifications — it is not a delicate eco-material but a performance-oriented synthetic that is built to hold up under the daily strain of streetwear use.","circular_design_and_recyclability":"Designed for end-of-life recyclability, Oleatex supports a circular material loop — meaning the Mary Janes' upper is conceived not as a single-use item but as part of a system where the material can be recovered and re-entered into production after the shoe is no longer wearable.","solvent_free_zero_water_production":"Oleatex is produced without solvents or water, eliminating both toxic chemical runoff and industrial water consumption during manufacturing — two hidden environmental tolls that often undercut the sustainability claims of conventional faux leathers.","embossable_and_color_matched_finish":"Oleatex can be embossed, dyed to any Pantone color, and worked with standard leather equipment, which allows Ganni to achieve a polished, deep-black patent-like sheen on the strap without using animal-derived or PVC-laden conventional vegan leather.","ganni_fabric_of_the_future_initiative":"Ganni included Oleatex in its Fabric of the Future initiative, a material innovation program launched in 2019 to scout and scale next-gen alternatives — tying these Mary Janes to a curated edit of forward-thinking materials that the brand bets on for its most directional footwear.","comparative_tearing_strength_advantage":"In a 2025 comparative evaluation, olive-waste-derived PU synthetic leather demonstrated superior tearing strength versus petroleum-based PU while maintaining excellent color fastness — a class-level performance finding that underpins the bio-based variant’s legitimacy as a technically competitive material, not just an eco-substitute."},"entry_quotes":{"75_olive_waste_conversion":[{"url":"https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex","quote":"Mediterranean olive pomace is a massive by-product of olive-oil production – 75% of every harvest becomes bio-residue."}],"up_to_90_bio_based_content":[{"url":"https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex","quote":"Up to 90% (ASTM D6866 verified)"}],"engineered_industrial_durability":[{"url":"https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex","quote":"Engineered for abrasion, flex, tear, and colour-fastness to meet industrial specs."}],"circular_design_and_recyclability":[{"url":"https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex","quote":"Designed for end-of-life recyclability within a circular material loop."}],"solvent_free_zero_water_production":[{"url":"https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex","quote":"Processed without water, solvent-free, and locally sourced within a 100 km radius of production"}],"embossable_and_color_matched_finish":[{"url":"https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex","quote":"Embossable, dyeable, and workable with standard leather-production equipment."}],"ganni_fabric_of_the_future_initiative":[{"url":"https://www.ganni.com/en/materials-index/oleatex.html","quote":"This material is part of our Fabric of the Future initiative, set up in 2019 to research, develop and invest in innovative materials that are paving the way for the future of fashion."}],"comparative_tearing_strength_advantage":[{"url":"https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=147951","quote":"The bio-based PU demonstrated superior tearing strength while maintaining comparable tensile strength and excellent color fastness properties."}]},"entry_sources":{"75_olive_waste_conversion":["https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex"],"up_to_90_bio_based_content":["https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex"],"engineered_industrial_durability":["https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex"],"circular_design_and_recyclability":["https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex"],"solvent_free_zero_water_production":["https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex"],"embossable_and_color_matched_finish":["https://oleatex.com/technology/oleatex"],"ganni_fabric_of_the_future_initiative":["https://www.ganni.com/en/materials-index/oleatex.html"],"comparative_tearing_strength_advantage":["https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=147951"]}},"oleatex_care_and_maintenance":{"title":"Care and maintenance for Oleatex","entries":{"heat_free_drying":"Direct sun and heat sources like radiators can warp the Oleatex material and accelerate hydrolysis; air-dry in a well-ventilated, shaded spot to maintain shape and material integrity after cleaning or exposure to moisture.","hydrolysis_vulnerability":"Because the Oleatex upper relies on a polyurethane binder that degrades through hydrolysis when moisture is trapped, air-drying the shoes thoroughly after wear and using moisture-absorbing inserts prevents the sticky, crumbly failure common in neglected PU-based footwear.","mild_soap_cleaning_ratio":"A 1:8 mild soap-to-water solution (as used for polyurethane materials) effectively removes dirt from the Oleatex upper without the solvent damage that harsh cleaners or alcohol can inflict on synthetic coatings — preserving the polished finish.","pu_protector_application":"A polyurethane-specific protector spray applied every 3–6 months (like COLOURLOCK PU Protector) creates a water-repellent barrier that reduces staining and slows moisture-driven breakdown of the bio-based Oleatex upper.","spot_testing_and_stain_removal":"Before cleaning, test any product on a hidden area; for oil stains, a baking soda paste left for 15–20 minutes absorbs grease safely, and a vinegar–water mixture lifts scuffs without degrading the Oleatex surface the way solvents might."},"entry_quotes":{"heat_free_drying":[{"url":"https://decentfoot.com/how-to-clean-pu-material-shoes/","quote":"Allow the shoes to air dry away from direct sunlight, which can warp the material."},{"url":"https://myshoesreview.com/blog/how-to-stop-hydrolysis-in-shoes/","quote":"Keep out of direct sun and heat sources."}],"hydrolysis_vulnerability":[{"url":"https://myshoesreview.com/blog/how-to-stop-hydrolysis-in-shoes/","quote":"Moisture sneaks into footwear and speeds up breakdown. This process, hydrolysis, weakens glues and fabrics over time."}],"mild_soap_cleaning_ratio":[{"url":"https://decentfoot.com/how-to-clean-pu-material-shoes/","quote":"Mix 1 part mild soap with 8 parts warm water to create a cleaning solution."}],"pu_protector_application":[{"url":"https://decentfoot.com/how-to-clean-pu-material-shoes/","quote":"Apply COLOURLOCK PU Protector every 3-6 months for maintenance."}],"spot_testing_and_stain_removal":[{"url":"https://leatherek.com/how-to-clean-vegan-leather-shoes/","quote":"For oil or grease-based stains, baking soda is your best tool. Create a paste by mixing baking soda with a small amount of water. Apply the paste directly to the stain and let it sit for about 15-20 minutes."}]},"entry_sources":{"heat_free_drying":["https://decentfoot.com/how-to-clean-pu-material-shoes/","https://myshoesreview.com/blog/how-to-stop-hydrolysis-in-shoes/"],"hydrolysis_vulnerability":["https://myshoesreview.com/blog/how-to-stop-hydrolysis-in-shoes/"],"mild_soap_cleaning_ratio":["https://decentfoot.com/how-to-clean-pu-material-shoes/"],"pu_protector_application":["https://decentfoot.com/how-to-clean-pu-material-shoes/"],"spot_testing_and_stain_removal":["https://leatherek.com/how-to-clean-vegan-leather-shoes/"]}}}},"handle":"eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women-19638-9726103","storefront_path":"/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103","storefront_url":"https://ai.simons.ca/en/women-footwear/all-our-shoes/eyelet-strap-notched-mary-janes-women--19638-9726103"}}